World War One Mystery

 
 

"Ivor, I am compiling a book about the Ballymena men who served in the Great War.
I have come across this character mentioned in an article published
in the Ballymena Observer in 1915 "

"His many friends in Ballymena and elsewhere will be pleased to learn that Sgt. W. J. Nesbitt, eldest son of Mr. Samuel Nesbitt, Flax Mill owner of Mount Street, Ballymena, and of the 1st Btn. Irish Guards, has been recommended for a commission and will in all probability be attached in future to the 4th (Service) Gloucester Regiment and will, he expects, be proceeding to a new sphere of operations on Friday after a few days¹ leave at home from Flanders where he has been for almost the past 12 months.
He has seen during this time, some very severe fighting and has himself been wounded by shell fire in the legs and had to undergo several attacks from gas from which he is still suffering and at times spitting up blood from the severe spasms of coughing.
He was mentioned in dispatches by Sir John French for distinguished bravery in holding a crater with a platoon of only 49 against outnumbering forces of Germans.
The Guards bombed the Germans out of this crater and had the distinction of holding it for 24 hours until reinforcements arrived.
Just as they were going down a communicating trench, one of Sgt. Nesbitt¹s comrades was killed by a shell. The Germans, unable to hold their position, withdrew and when Sgt. Nesbitt¹s gallant little force returned to their quarters that night there were only 11 to answer the roll call.
At the recent battle at Hulluch, they were ordered to storm the line of enemy trenches which they did with all the dash and gallanty associated with this historic regiment, but in a dug-out they discovered 10 Germans in hiding and firing for all they were worth.
On seeing them, Sgt. Nesbitt dashed upon them and fired ten rounds into their trench killing every one of them. Fearing lest any of then might only be wounded and escape, he jumped into the dug-out, rifle in hand and bayonetted the entire lot amidst the cheers of the few comrades who witnessed his heroism.
Sgt. Nesbitt who is come of a good old fighting stock, was through all the South African war and his two brothers, Riflemen Tom and Robert Nesbitt are at present attached to the 18th Btn. RIR".   Ballymena Observer, October 29, 1915
      

 "I have checked medal index cards etc and with the Glos. Regimental Museum ... they have no record of any officer of this description.  I can find no reference to this event in Kipling and have put the story on a very popular WW1 Forum to no avail.
Could you help? Perhaps someone in RHQ could have access to the unit war diary? I have come to the conclusion that the man did exist as a Corporal in the Irish Guards at the time ... but the story is a 'little' incredible. Sounds a little like the O'Leary VC action? "
Des Blackadder
Editor
Ballymena Times and Observer.
Perhaps you or your visitors know someone who might be able to help?